Perfect Hard-Boiled Eggs (Buying Tips and Cooking Instructions)

10 Mar

We love eggs around here and Leandro especially likes them hard-boiled. One of our favorite laid-back dinners is hard-boiled eggs with broiled asparagus. Olive oil to coat the asparagus and a bit of salt for both eggs and vegetable is all the seasoning we need.

The length of time it takes to bring the water to a boil when the water covers the eggs by an inch is the magic time period!

The length of time it takes to bring the water to a boil when the water covers the eggs by an inch is the magic time period!

As you might guess, I almost invariably buy organic eggs when I buy in the supermarket and from local folks whenever possible. And yeah, they tend to cost a lot more. To me they are worth it in terms of better conditions for the hens and less chance of harmful chemicals for my son.

The taste however? Well I don’t find any appreciable difference. It is mostly when I buy local free-range eggs that I notice a difference in the vibrancy of the yolk color and the intensity of flavor.

Leandro's favorite breakfast. Or lunch. Or dinner.

Leandro’s favorite breakfast. Or lunch. Or dinner.

And don’t be fooled by granola coloring. Brown and white eggs have the same nutritional value; the color of the eggs depends on the species. I think most supermarket organic eggs are brown because we consumers  connect brown food with healthier food (whole wheat bread vs. white; whole grain pasta; brown sugar), but really there is no difference (and this becomes annoying at Easter when I can’t find organic white eggs for coloring the eggs!). For a more extensive explanation of what the different egg labels mean and whether there are nutritional benefits to paying more, click here.

Now, you’d assume that you want the freshest of eggs to hard boil, but that is not at all the case.

When eggs are fresh they are very dense and will sink to the bottom of a bowl of water when uncooked. The yolk and white fill the shell to its maximum capacity and therefore, when you try to peel it the shell won’t separate and it cracks and takes chunk of egg white with it and is generally quite annoying. As the egg gets older, it loses some moisture through the shell. The inner membrane separates a bit from the shell, especially at the wider end. An air pocket will form there and if you place the raw egg in a bowl of water, the air pocket end will float up. The egg is still quite fresh enough to eat, but now will be easier to peel because the membrane is looser. So don’t use the freshest eggs for hard-boiling!

When the egg is too fresh, peeling becomes a challenge.

When the egg is too fresh, peeling becomes a challenge.

And do shock them in ice water. The theory is that the shock of the cold also causes the membrane to retract and become easier to peel, plus you want the cooking to stop when the egg is perfect. Don’t ask me where I got the theory, because I can’t remember whether it was Cook’s Illustrated, some T.V. show, or at an egg seminar by Chef Dan Barber at Stone Barns a few years back. (yes, I have been known to go to egg seminars for entertainment).

Anyhoo, for creamy yolk with no uncooked bits and no dusty overcookedness or green ring and a white that squeaks and is not rubbery, following these simple steps virtually guarantees success. Every time.

Creamy, perfectly cooked yolk. One of life’s simplest pleasures.

Perfect Hard-Boiled Eggs

Place desired number of eggs in a pot.

Add enough cold water to cover eggs by about an inch.

Heat water to boiling.

Remove from heat.

Cover and allow to sit for ten minutes (15 if you are a Nervous Nelly, but you really don’t need 15 and you risk overcooking).

Drain and shock in ice water for at least five minutes. Done!

You May Also Like:

Delicious and Devilish Eggs

Duck or Hen’s Egg Frittata

Spaghetti a la carbonara (Bacon and Eggs the Italian Way)

Tortilla Torcal (the ultimate Spanish style frittata, with ham and chorizo)

Amped-Up Egg Salad


10 Responses to “Perfect Hard-Boiled Eggs (Buying Tips and Cooking Instructions)”

  1. Alexandra March 17, 2013 at 5:08 pm #

    Who inspired this posting!?!? Haha

  2. Conor Bofin March 11, 2013 at 5:16 pm #

    I haven’t boiled an egg in ages. Lovely done soft with toast fingers. Good advice for the summer salads, if we ever see summer again….

  3. Adam J. Holland March 11, 2013 at 11:38 am #

    You’d be surprised (or maybe you wouldn’t) at how often I have to consult my notes on properly boiling an egg. Thank you for this information! Bookmarked (and hopefully memorized at some point)!

  4. Karen March 11, 2013 at 9:28 am #

    Good tips. We get fresh eggs every week from a friend. To help peel the very fresh eggs which can sometimes be difficult, I add about a tsp. of vinegar to the water.

  5. Mad Dog March 11, 2013 at 7:59 am #

    Great tips! Cecilia wrote that she steams them and in doing so they are easier to peel…

  6. arzainal March 10, 2013 at 10:05 pm #

    Reblogged this on


  1. Two New Natural Easter Egg Colors | Hot, Cheap & Easy - April 1, 2015

    […] Save the papery bits of red onion and yellow onion until you have a generous handful (the papery skins of a two-pound bag of onions should do it). Place each color in its own saucepan with 2.5 Cups water and a teaspoon salt. Bring to a boil and then lower heat to a lively simmer for 10 minutes. Strain into your dipping container, stir in 2 Tbs white vinegar and you are ready to dip! (For perfect hard-boiled eggs, click here) […]

Talk foodie to me, baby...

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: